eCom Holidays

What Actually Makes People Buy on Black Friday? 

SHARE:
Share
Copy

The Summary

Black Friday isn’t only about offering the biggest discount.

For wall-art sellers, it can be more effective to use the sale to make better products easier to justify: framed instead of unframed, larger instead of smaller, or a coordinated gallery set instead of one print.

Start communicating early, keep the offer simple, use real holiday shipping deadlines, and prepare your fulfillment before increasing traffic. The discount gets attention. The way the offer is built is what makes someone buy.

Black Friday started with chaos

Long before Black Friday meant discount codes and overflowing shopping carts, the name usually meant something had gone wrong.

One famous Black Friday happened in 1869, when financiers Jay Gould and James Fisk attempted to manipulate the US gold market. The scheme collapsed, gold prices crashed and the day became known as Black Friday.

The modern shopping meaning came later. In Philadelphia during the 1950s and 1960s, the name was used for the traffic, crowds and chaos that followed Thanksgiving. Retailers eventually transformed an unpleasant nickname into the biggest shopping event of the year.

It is a fitting history, because for a few days every November, normal ideas about price become slightly distorted.

A purchase that felt expensive last week suddenly feels reasonable.

Understanding why is more useful than simply deciding whether your discount should be 20% or 30%.

A deal only works if people believe it

Shoppers actively search for Black Friday discounts, but that doesn’t mean they automatically trust them.

DHL’s 2025 research found that 71% of shoppers are motivated by Black Friday discounts, while only 50% completely or mostly trust retailers’ Black Friday prices and offers.

That creates a simple problem.

If your store constantly says:

€120 → €59

customers eventually start wondering whether €120 was ever the real price.

A Black Friday promotion works better when the normal value of the product already feels believable.

For wall-art sellers, that often means keeping the offer straightforward:

20% off framed prints.

Buy two prints and save 25%.

One clear offer can feel stronger than several discounts, pop-ups, countdowns and coupon 

wheels competing for attention.

Don't just make the cheapest product cheaper

One of the more interesting effects of holiday sales is that shoppers don't necessarily choose the cheapest option.

Adobe found that during the 2025 US holiday season, the share of products sold from the highest-priced tier increased compared with the rest of the year.

A sale can therefore help customers trade up.

For wall art, that might mean:

poster → framed poster
canvas → framed canvas
small print → statement size
one artwork → coordinated set

Instead of asking:

How cheaply can we sell this poster?

ask:

Can Black Friday make the version they actually want easier to afford?

That is often a much better way to increase order value than simply cutting prices across the entire catalog.

Sell the finished wall

Bundles are usually discussed as an AOV tactic.

For wall art, they can do something more useful: remove decisions.

Customers buying several prints have to decide whether the colors work together, which sizes to choose, how many pieces they need and whether the frames match.

A curated gallery set solves part of that problem for them.

You're no longer selling:

three separate prints.

You're selling:

the finished wall.

That could mean a matching triptych, a large central artwork paired with two smaller prints, or a ready-made gallery arrangement with sizes already chosen.

The discount then becomes another reason to buy the complete solution rather than the reason the bundle exists.

Use urgency that's actually real

Black Friday shoppers have seen enough fake urgency to recognize it.

ONLY 2 LEFT.

17 PEOPLE ARE VIEWING THIS.

SALE ENDS IN 09:42:16.

For print-on-demand sellers, that kind of pressure is often unnecessary because the holiday season already gives you something better: real deadlines.

A custom wall-art order has to be produced, packed, shipped and delivered before Christmas.

So communicate that clearly.

Order by December X for expected Christmas delivery.

If a promotion actually ends Sunday, say so.

Real production and shipping cut-offs create urgency while also helping customers make a better decision. Just avoid promising guaranteed delivery unless your fulfillment setup genuinely supports it.

Start early — without making November one long sale

Black Friday planning should begin before Black Friday.

That doesn't mean running the discount for the whole month.

Use the first half of November to:

  • tease the offer;
  • give existing customers early access;
  • build your email list;
  • test which products and room mockups perform best;
  • identify winning ads before competition becomes most expensive.

Recent BFCM campaign analysis has also shown that strong evergreen ads often continue to perform during Black Friday when the offer is simply added to them.

That makes sense.

People still need to want the artwork before they care that it is 25% off.

Make every extra visitor worth more

BFCM advertising becomes expensive, so improving the value of existing traffic can matter as much as finding more of it.

Instead of adding random checkout accessories, focus on upgrades that make sense for the product:

  • offer a larger size;
  • recommend the framed version;
  • show matching artworks;
  • create two- or three-print sets;
  • use spend thresholds for genuinely useful bonuses.

Retargeting also becomes especially valuable over Black Friday weekend.

Someone who viewed a framed print on Thursday but didn't buy doesn't necessarily need to see a completely different ad on Cyber Monday. Showing them the artwork they already considered, now with a clear final offer or shipping deadline, is usually the more logical message.

Don't scale traffic before checking fulfillment

Black Friday is marketed as a traffic problem.

Eventually it becomes an operations problem.

Before increasing ad spend, sellers should know:

  • which products they want to promote;
  • expected production times;
  • holiday shipping cut-offs;
  • which countries can realistically receive orders before Christmas;
  • and how delays or damaged orders will be handled.

Wall art can be large, fragile and made to order. A record weekend isn't particularly useful if January is spent replacing rushed orders and handling complaints.

Your fulfillment partner needs to be part of the Black Friday plan, not something you think about after the ads start working.

One new traffic source worth watching in 2026

Some holiday shoppers are now starting their research inside AI tools.

They might ask:

What wall art should I buy someone who just moved?

Canvas or framed poster for a living room?

Best minimalist wall-art gift under $100?

Adobe reported a major year-over-year increase in AI-referred traffic to US retail sites during the 2025 holiday season, with those visitors also converting at a higher rate than other traffic during Black Friday.

For sellers, the lesson is simple:

Make your products easy to understand.

Clearly explain materials, sizes, frame options, shipping, product differences and who each format is best suited for. Good product information helps customers once they reach your store — and increasingly, it may also help them discover it.

A better Black Friday strategy

Black Friday doesn't fundamentally change why people buy wall art.

They still want something that makes an empty wall feel better.

The sale simply changes the moment when they decide to buy it.

So instead of trying to win by shouting the largest discount, use BFCM to make the decision easier:

make the better product attainable, build bundles that solve a real problem, use genuine deadlines, recover shoppers who already showed interest and make sure fulfillment can handle the traffic you create.

The best Black Friday offer doesn't only look cheaper.

It makes the customer feel like now is the right moment to buy what they already wanted.

Found the article insightful? Share it!
Share
Copy

Most Popular

Stay in the loop with Printseekers!

Drop your e-mail to join our e-mail list and be the first to get the news about Printseekers!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.